Product….Project….AAAAHHHHH Whats the difference?

Product….Project….AAAAHHHHH Whats the difference?

For the better part of my entire adult career one common question / problem has always plagued me. As a seasoned Product Manager with over 10+ years experience  it’s so common to get confused questions….are you a Project Manager? Can I get a Project plan? Whats your resource plan look like for this project? It goes on and on and on till I want to pull my hair out. Needless to say this is a topic very near and dear to my heart….so lets tackle the dreaded Product vs Project question once and for all! First up lets take a trip down Product lane!

 

Product Definition

product is the value proposition you are delivering to a user. It can be anything: a physical product that you hold in your hands, a software application, or a service that you are delivering.

Product Manager role

What is a product manager? Product managers are often described as the Servant Leaders of their products setting strategy, prioritize releases, talk to customers, and clearly define features. A product manager’s goal is to deliver a product that delivers end user value.

Product Manager’s responsibilities

The product manager is responsible for setting the product strategy. By having a “goal first” approach to managing and building the product, great product managers can create initiatives to help reach those goals. Product managers must answer these questions:

What problem does this solve?”

“What are you building?”

“What will the benefits be?”

 

Product managers own:

Strategy

Releases

Ideation

Features

Go-to-Market

Organizational training

Profit and Loss

 

Now lets take a look at the flip side and dive deep into the Project side of the house

Project Definition 

In contrast, project is a plan with a series of activities that has a defined outcome and a fixed start and end date. The project is completed when that outcome is accomplished.

Project Manager Role

What is a project manager? Project managers oversee a fixed project from beginning to end. It can be a single project or a group of projects. Their job is to execute the strategy set by the product manager or leadership team. A project manager’s goal is to work with a broader team with a diverse set of skills and to complete a project on time and under budget.

Project Manager’s responsibilities 

The project manager is often less concerned with specific product goals and focused on the project itself. A project manager takes product initiatives and features to develop a timeline based on any potential constraints related to resources, risks, or scope. Project managers must answer the questions, “What resources are needed?” And, “When will the project get delivered?” And, “Who is going to do what?”

Project managers own:

Budget

Delivery

Resources

Capacity

Cross-team organization

Problem resolution

Status updates

 

This is really just the tip of the iceberg but hopefully this helps make things a bit more clear on the two very different roles, in a future blog I’ll touch on the role of product owner and how it fits in the above.

 

Don’t let your entrepreneurial spirit wither and die on the vine

Don’t let your entrepreneurial spirit wither and die on the vine

I was recently having a conversation with an entrepreneurial friend of mine about some of the struggles he was having and something hit me. He’s clearly not treating his entrepreneurial spirit like a cash crop. The spirit is just like something you would plant in your back yard, it has certain needs that must be met in order to grow and flourish.

My friend was getting bogged down in the day to day grind and struggling to recharge his batteries. After listening to his problem I was able to quickly give him some advice on how to solve his problem. I simply told him “You need more Green time and less Screen time.” He looked at me like I was speaking a foreign language or had introduced some mind boggling concept so we dove into it.

Sometimes the easiest way to get a fresh perspective on things is to change your surroundings. I’m a huge fan of trying to get outside as much as possible. A little “Green Time” is a great way to recharge the batteries and take a moment to get away from the working grind.

One of the easiest ways to give your entrepreneurial spirit what it needs to thrive is get outside, change your perspective, get a little fresh air to help refocus yourself.

In today’s fully connected times no one is every really “out of the office” so its easy to get out on a walking meeting or get some green time and still be fully engaged in your work day.

 

Don’t let your entrepreneurial spirit wither and die on the vine, give it the Green time it needs

Failed business transformation through the eyes of an immunologist

Failed business transformation through the eyes of an immunologist

I was recently reading an exchange between Dr. Kristina Talbert-Slagle and retired Army General Stanley McChrystal comparing how a virus like HIV or AIDS works to how an insurgency like Al Qaeda in Iraq works and I was more then a little surprised at the similarities. I went on to make the same correlations that McChrystal himself makes in the fantastic book Team of Teams in comparing those same viruses to the struggles an Organization sees during a failed business transformation.

When someone contracts something like HIV or AIDS its never the actual virus itself that kills a person, the virus weakens the body’s immune system allowing it to fall victim to any number of otherwise non fatal infections. Organizations struggling with transformation often face the same problems. It’s extremely common for an organization under transformation to run into any number of expected non threatening challenges, however the true death of the transformation comes as a result of chasing down and trying to resolve all the “symptoms” of those normal non threatening challenges. When an organization shifts it’s focus away from the larger trans formative activities it falls victim to the death of a thousand cuts as it continues to chase down small out lying issues.

In business transformation, much like our own person health, its important to treat the symptom of the problem but the far more critical issue is getting to the bottom of the route cause and not losing sight of the larger transformation. It’s always easier to view each problem in a vacuum but the key is to take a step back and see how the current problem is interacting with the organizational echo system. Viewing the problem from this 10,000 foot level allows you to see the problem in its environment and better understand how the problem is interlinked with unexpected areas.

How failing fast dominated the Steel industry

How failing fast dominated the Steel industry

Was recently reading the story of Frederick Winslow Taylor‘s display at the 1900 Paris Exposition Universelle and was extremely amazed how Taylor was able to take a favorite agile mantra of mine, failing fast, and really revolutionize the steel industry. At the time it was common place for a steel mill to produce roughly 9 feet of steel per minute. The presentation which was a smaller replica of Taylor’s factory was able to product steel at a staggering 50 feet per minute. Taylor’s breakthrough was often compared to the creation of the electric light and was even refereed to as a major landmark in the history of mankind. But how was Taylor able to create such a mind boggling achievement? Magic? A pact with the devil? The answer lies in one of the great hallmarks of agile transformation….Taylor was largely able to accomplish this through trial and error, or as we like to call it, failing fast.

Through a series of experiments Taylor had determined the perfect conditions for creating steel, everything from the optimal temp to cut the steel, the optimal method to use water to cool the lathe, and the optimal speed to run the conveyor belts.

 

Taylor was able to revolutionize the steel industry by simply approaching his processes with a healthy curiosity for improvement and a willingness to fail fast. Sure in the early days his progress was very poor and unprofitable but by persevering through the difficult times and staying focused on the end game Taylor was able to rise to complete dominance in his industry

 

 

The story of Proteus and Menelaus

I’m often asked how I ended up going into an Agile / Business transformation career, the answer is pretty simple, I just sort of fell into it and quickly found out it was something I was pretty good at. The story of Proteus and Menelaus always appealed to me and to this day is still a story I like to tell at the start of a new Agile or Business transformation.

 

Returning home after the Trojan war Menelaus’s ship was becalmed on the isle of Pharos, after spending 20 days waiting for favorable winds a Nymph named Eidothea explains that only Proteus can help Menelaus get home and that only by capturing Proteus will Menelaus ever get favorable winds to return home. Eidothea explains the only way to capture Proteus is by surprise and helps Menelaus hatch a plan to capture Proteus after he falls asleep. She told him there is a certain cave where seals sleep that Proteus goes to at dawn. Menelaus and two chosen men were to go there and hide among the seals and grab Proteus by surprise. They were to hold on no matter what form he changed into. When he stopped changing, then Menelaus could ask him which god was angry with them, then they could sacrifice to that god. Menelaus and his men snuck into the cave before dawn and grabbed Proteus when he came to look over the seals. He changed into animals and trees and tried to frighten them, but they did not let go.

 

This story always struck me as extremely interesting as Menelaus had to push past constant change while keeping a single goal in mind. This has always been a powerful story in helping drive home the perseverance needed to successfully transform a business.  During the transformation you might has to go through several stages each trying to throw you off course but the critical part is to always keep your end goal in mind and try to hold on for the ride!